Why Blind Tasting
The Label Is Lying to You
The label changes how whisky tastes. This is not a metaphor. It is a documented psychological phenomenon. In multiple studies, tasters presented with the same whisky in labelled and unlabelled glasses have rated them significantly differently – scoring the labelled version higher when the label was prestigious and lower when they were told it was cheap. The brain does not experience whisky purely through the nose and palate. It processes expectation, memory, price, and reputation alongside flavour. The label is part of the drink.
Blind tasting removes this interference. It forces you to engage with what is actually in the glass rather than what you expect to find there. The result, for most people, is humbling and liberating in equal measure. Expressions you dismissed because of their reputation often show genuinely well. Bottles you paid a premium for sometimes disappoint without the label to prompt appreciation.
“Blind tasting is not about showing off. It is about honesty. You and the whisky, with nothing else in between.”
Professional whisky competitions are conducted blind for exactly this reason. The results regularly surprise even experienced judges – which is the point. If you want to know what you actually like rather than what you think you should like, blind tasting is the only honest method. It is also the fastest way to develop your palate, because it forces you to build and test your own framework rather than relying on someone else’s notes.
The Systematic Method
How to Work Through a Blind Dram
Blind tasting without a system is just guessing. A system gives you a series of questions to answer in order, each of which narrows down the possibilities. The questions move from broad to specific – from “what style is this?” to “which distillery could this be?” You will not always reach a definitive answer. The goal is to get as close as possible through evidence, not intuition.
Reading the Clues
What Each Note Tells You
Every note in a whisky is a clue. Some clues are reliable – peat strongly suggests Islay or a small number of peated Highland producers. Some clues are ambiguous – vanilla could be bourbon cask, virgin oak, or a natural fermentation compound. The skill of blind tasting is learning which clues are strong signals and which are noise.
Strong signal for Islay. Ardbeg, Laphroaig, Lagavulin. Also possible: heavily peated Highland (Ardmore, Benriach peated). Less likely: Speyside, Lowlands.
Ex-bourbon cask. Could be almost any region. Narrows to bourbon-matured expressions. Common in Speyside and Highland at standard ages.
Sherry cask – most likely Oloroso. Points toward GlenDronach, Glenfarclas, Aberlour, Macallan Sherry Oak. Age likely 12+ years.
Long fermentation esters, or warm climate maturation. Points toward Kavalan, some Indian malts, or distilleries with long fermentation (Springbank, some Speysides).
Worm tub condenser. Strong signal for Clynelish, Springbank, Dalwhinnie, Mortlach, Glen Scotia. The waxiness is a genuine house signature.
Tall stills. Points toward Glenmorangie, Hakushu, some Lowland expressions. Usually lower ABV or ex-bourbon matured. Rarely from heavily sherried or peated whisky.
Bourbon – American origin strongly indicated. Or grain whisky in a blend. The sweetness character is distinctively American oak in new barrels.
Rye grain – American rye whiskey or a high-rye bourbon mashbill. Also possible in Irish pure pot still (though softer). Rarely found in Scotch.
Calling everything Speyside when you detect fruit. Assuming peat means Islay when Highland peated expressions exist. Confusing natural sulphur complexity with a faulty bottle. Underestimating age when a light expression matures slowly. Overestimating age when a first-fill cask matures quickly. The answer is usually simpler than you think – start with the broad category and work inward.
Running a Blind Tasting
How to Set One Up Properly
Blind tastings are more fun and more useful when they are structured. A random collection of glasses is less valuable than a flight built around a theme – same distillery across different ages, same region across different producers, same cask type across different styles. The theme gives you reference points, and reference points are what teach you.
Pour 3-6 whiskies into numbered glasses before guests arrive. Keep the bottles out of sight. Give each taster a sheet with the numbers and space to write notes. Work through each glass using the systematic method. After everyone has noted their assessments, reveal the whiskies. The reveal is always the most instructive moment – it shows you where your framework works and where it needs development.
Useful flight themes for beginners: bourbon cask vs sherry cask (same distillery if possible – Glenmorangie Original vs Lasanta is a classic); peated vs unpeated (Bunnahabhain 12 vs Laphroaig 10 from the same island shows how much production choice matters); same age across regions (12-year-old Speyside vs Highland vs Islay vs Lowland).
Number of whiskies: three is ideal for beginners – enough to make comparisons without overwhelming the palate. Five or six works for more experienced tasters. Beyond six, palate fatigue sets in and the later samples suffer. Always start with the lightest whisky and move to the most assertive – starting with Laphroaig and then trying a Lowland single malt is like trying to hear a whisper after a fire alarm.
Cleansing the palate: plain still water between samples. Plain crackers or bread if needed. Avoid strong food, coffee, or anything that leaves a residual taste. And do not rinse glasses with water between samples – the water changes the glass and affects the next pour.
“The reveal is where blind tasting becomes education. Every surprise is a lesson. Every correct call is confirmation that your framework is working.”
Test Your
Knowledge
5 questions. No time limit. Select your answer and submit when ready.